
In its British version
Counternarratives continues to earn reviews, and I am very happy to report a rare
trifecta in the
Times Literary Supplement. (I say this not to humblebrag but out of real astonishment; other than the
Wall Street Journal, not a single major US newspaper save the
Wall Street Journal reviewed
Counternarratives, though thankfully many magazines, journals and independent reviews more than made up for the big press's silence.) To the
TLS, I say thank you, and thanks again!
First, critic
Kate Webb published the
longest, most rhapsodic and perspicacious of the three, entitled "Exceed Every Limit." It was one of the best reviews the book has received so far. Here is one quote I particularly enjoy, as she identifies one of my key intellectual-genealogical through-lines, via the greats
Edward Said and
Paul Gilroy. She also teaches me a new word, "polytych":
As its title suggests, Counternarratives contains “writing back” of the kind Edward Said once proposed; its stories are imbued with potent dialectical energy, bringing to mind Paul Gilroy’s key idea of the “Black Atlantic as a counterculture of modernity”. Keene is not simply an oppositional writer, however: in his richly detailed accounts of black lives through history, dividing lines are continually crossed. So there are escapologists and prophets, motifs of cultural appropriation, false consciousness, prohibited desire, illicit knowledge, forbidden artistry, and everywhere the struggle for transcendence. Counternarratives consists of thirteen individual fictions – some of flashing brevity, others the length and intricacy of a novella. Together they act like a polytych: each story has its own integrity but an underlying intellectual coherence allows the reader to intimate their author’s power and purpose, and to identify the arrival of a writer who, like one of his own characters, has “a will of lead and a satin tongue”.
Another very positive
TLS notice came from fiction editor
Toby Lichtig, who decided to create his
own alternative Man Booker Prize longlist of the "top thirteen novels from the past year," and placing
Counternarratives on it, with in the aim in part to include "a little bit more experimental writing" than this year's Man Booker Prize committee did. He mentions Kate Webb's review specifically in his comments:
Our [TLS] reviewer...was hugely impressed by this dazzling retelling of colonial history in the Americas, a "writing back" inspired by writers from Jean Rhys to Edward Said but achieved with a unique vision that is all the author's own. "We have", wrote Webb, "become accustomed in recent years to the revisionary spirit of much postcolonial fiction, but the ambition, erudition and epic sweep of John Keene’s remarkable new collection of stories, travelling from the beginnings of modernity to modernism, place it in a class of its own."
Lastly, as I mentioned a few posts ago, in
TLS's suggested summer reading list, critic and author
Ben Eastham placed it "at the summit" of his book stack, adding:
Keene is among the contemporary American writers pushing at the boundaries of fiction, his angry, exhilarating stories about race and American history another counter-example (if it were needed) to the lazy assumption that literary innovation should be confined to the ivory tower.
To Webb, Lichtig and Eastham, and to the
TLS I offer my heartfelt thanks!
***
I am always surprised when people ask me if it is OK to conduct an interview, because until
Counternarratives I had participated in so few, and I relish opportunities to answer questions, no matter how challenging, about my work. For me these interviews are always conversations, and if they bring more readers to my writing or to that of the interviewer or interviewers, or to any of the people I mention in passing, so much the better.
One fruit of such a conversation recently appeared in
Cosmonauts Avenue,
which published a chat I had with one of my and our brilliant
Rutgers-Newark MFA students,
Soili Smith, who when she's not producing writing of impressive depth and philosophical heft, is supervising tree planting in
British Columbia. It was a joy to speak with Soili, and I hope readers found something interesting in the interview, which actually covers some new ground, I think!
A long quote, about
novellas--we can never have enough of that form, can we?: